Quote:

Not sure what the difference is between the xs and the hse,

I briefly had a 2010 HSE TD4 before changing it for my XS - to me the noticeable differences were:-
Better Stereo, extra speakers in the D-pillar make a big difference
Sunroof (was an option on the XS)
memory function on the driver's seat - useful when SWMBO is vertically challenged... I think the mirrors on the doors had memory settings too...
Genuine plastic wood trim on the dashboard...
IIRC the mirrors dipped when reverse was selected...
The HSE has a spoiler on the tailgate - which does nothing other than increase your chances of being rear-ended by an HGV by masking the 3rd brake light...

Good luck with whatever you decide as the replacement vehicle and i hope you get everything resolved soon.

Just a quick query, are sd4s autos booked at higher retail value than a td4 manual for similar model cars, found a few td4 xs manuals, but need auto for towing.

@Chrism551 - If i understood the question right, is a SD4 Auto XS a higher book value than a TD4 manual XS (same age / mileage/ condition etc.)? Answer - yes, SD4 auto has a higher book value - it is a more powerful vehicle with a more sophisticated transmission. But remember, because of the age of these vehicles now, low mileage and a good service history will hold more weight in the trades's book value than extra power & toys inside the cabin.

If you need to tow, stick with the SD4 Auto. The TD4 Auto has a flatter torque / power curve than the SD4 - so less of a grin when dragging boat / caravan / horsebox / whatever up a steep gradient...

Good luck with the search & do let us know what you eventually decide on...