Loads of tyre threads but I couldn't find one to answer this question.

As it say in the title really - both are available for 235/55/19 and I don't really want AT (although they look good!) but the Pirelli is currently £10 each less expensive.

Has anyone had experience of the Pirelli, my previous FL2's had Goodyears which seemed to do what I need them to to.

Thanks

I have had both, I recall the Goodyear being a little quieter. Both gripped well in dry and wet.
They are so close, that unless you have a preference on tread pattern, I would get the cheapest. 

I ran 18" Scorpion Zero's on my previous FL2 with great results and this one is running Scorpion Verde's, also with good results so far. Quiet, even tread wear, good grip and about 6mm left after running approx 15,000 miles including a large mileage in towing.

Anyone experience of the Verdes in ice/snow ?

pcheaven wrote:

I have had both, I recall the Goodyear being a little quieter. Both gripped well in dry and wet.
They are so close, that unless you have a preference on tread pattern, I would get the cheapest.

sorry, I dont recall on the mileage

Only had my DS for a week, its a keeper.
 

unfortunately I've only run the Wranglers after buying the car with 2 different brands on it

I've found them to be very reasonable on the motorway, grip will in the wet and performed flawlessly in the snow last winter. I'll be getting them again

this is of interest to me as well

on our FL1 we ran P Scorpion STRs which were really good hence I'm very tempted with the Verdes

We ran STR's on my wife's Tiguan, they seemed to work ok but the tread always held on to gravel and small stones.

Hi BRD, I have posted somewhere on this before, Pirelli's gets my vote:

Fitted Scorpion Verde All seasons (235/55 R19) Oct 2013 and did 54000 KM's on them in all kinds of conditions and have just replaced with the same before winter arrives here in Switzerland. On road grip & road holding in wet and dry never any issues, fine on both loose snow and packed snow/ice conditions up in ski areas at temperatures down to -28 deg C. Last summer we drove to Croatia for our holiday (4 people + big dog + 630L roof box) no issues getting there and back and off road on mainly rock with lots of loose stones & gravel they experienced +42 deg C and were excellent throughout. Also I've never noticed any noise issues.
Cheeers,
Mick

After that recommend I am going to keep the Verdes on for the winter , thanks for the feedback .

You know this, but just to be clear ('cos I'm anal like that...)

Scorpion Verde and Scorpion Verde All Season are very different tyres. Make sure you get the ones you want!

Good point, they are very different tyres!

I think I am going to go for the Pirelli Scorpion Verde's. £112 each delivered in VAT! Freelander 2 HSE Lux 2013MY - Barolo Black with Ivory Leather. Alpine DVD - Privacy -Evoque 20" Dynamic Wheels and more to come.........

This may help

http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Tyre/Pirelli/...Season.htm

Can you be more specific re Wrangler Tyres

On that tyre review link someone is moaning abouth them being harsh .... on an XJ6